A CHRISTIAN SCIENCE HEALING - 1970
When Mary Baker Eddy, the discoverer and founder of Christian Science, created the religion in the late 19th Century hospitals were places you went to die. There was no such thing as penicillin. Doctors could only set bones, give you glasses and pull teeth. So Mary told her flock that they may seek medical care for broken bones, eye-glasses and teeth only. She said that for other diseases the cure was to know that they were unreal-- and that as soon as you recognized this fact that they would disappear.
In 1969, when penicillin had been around for 24 years, and doctors could cure a thousand diseases, I made one last visit to mine. Dr. Lionel J. Pepperman was a big, swarthy, gentle pediatrician, whose offices were attached to his house on Farview Avenue. He had medical instruments made out of chrome and Bakelite. I sat on butcher-paper and broke out in goose bumps when Dr. Pepperman asked me if I had a girlfriend. The back of my neck got this fantastic rush of tingles while I thought of all the things I would tell him about Amanda Clemmons, the girl I was in love with, if only I had the nerve to speak. Which, I never did.
Dr. Pepperman had a beige telephone with push button dialing. His fingers smelled like Dial and Kools. And when he gave shots, like for the mumps you could feel the needle go into your arm, but there was no pain.
Still my time with Dr. Pepperman was coming to an end. My mom was a Christian Scientist, named Mary after Mary Baker Eddy herself. My mom a half-Armenian, half-Russian Jew, born in the northeast corner of Tabriz, Iran – the capital of Azeri Persia was in fact named after the WASP discoverer and founder of a marginal Boston-based metaphysical offshoot of Congregationalism. Now I may be going out on a limb here, but I would even hazard a guess that my mom is the only half-Armenian, half-Russian Jew born in an Azeri area of Persia who is named for the blueblood Bostonian founder of a pseudo-ontological Nuevo-Christian denomination… at least the only one in her neighborhood.
About six months after I last saw my pediatrician, I told my mom that I had a 24-hour bug. She asked if I wanted to go to Dr. Pepperman, or did I want her to call Mr. Hoffnung whom I wouldn't have to see. He would pray for me remotely from his home.
You see, Bud Hoffnung was a Christian Science Practitioner. If Dr. Pepperman was nice, Mr. Hoffnung was someone from fairy tale land. He was Mr. Rogers wrapped in a Burl Ives container, filled with love and smiles. And let me tell you something, whatever I may think of Christian Science today, or what you may think of Christian Science today, Mr. Hoffnung was perhaps one of the nicest, kindest, most genuine human beings you could possibly ever meet in your life.
And, if my mom called Mr. Hoffnung, I didn’t have to go anywhere. I could stay home and watch television while my parents paid him to pray for me. Wonder which one I chose?
So I curled up on the mustard coach in our living room, under my blanket and my bedspread, and I watched Captain Kangaroo, Mr. Roger’s Neighborhood, Courageous Cat and Minute Mouse, Gigantor: The Space Age Robot, Lassie, The Lucy Show, The Adams Family, Bachelor Father, Gilligan’s Island, Felix the Cat, Dodo the Kid from Outer Space, and Lost in Space.
All the while, Mr. Hoffnung prayed for me, utilizing the Divine Healing Power of Christian Science in order to see me as God's Perfect Child. This allowed him to heal me by fighting off the Mental Malpractice that had told me that I was sick. And sure enough, the following morning, twenty-four hours after I came down with a 24-hour bug, I was healed – healed without ever once stepping foot within a doctor's office, healed through the power of Divine Love, healed through the power of Christian Science prayer.
Was this the greatest discovery ever? I could be sick whenever I wanted or needed to be and I never had to be checked on again. All I had to do was say I was sick and bingo… we would call Mr. Hoffnung, he would pray for me, and I could watch TV.
Still, there was a catch, because when you have a Christian Science healing, it was hoped that you might give testimony. Christian Science churches had Wednesday Night services, at which one stands up and tells of their healing. I remember at one of the Wednesday Night testimonials one elderly lady saying that she had had something in her eye and at that moment when the pain was the most excruciating; that Divine Mind put a commercial on her television that told her to pull her upper eyelid over her lower eyelid to get rid of the object. She tried this and the item came out, proving God's love.
Between testimonies, the First Reader gazed out at the congregation with a beautiful smile. The First Reader was an elected member of the congregation who led all church services. In Christian Science our preachers were the Bible and The Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures by Mary Baker Eddy. Thus, we only needed a fellow member of the church, a reader to read these to the congregation.
I sat in the pews knowing I should rise and tell my story of being healed from a 24-hour bug in 24-hours. Mr. James, the First Reader cast his smile over to me. It was dark outside and I could feel the cold that had soaked into the windows. My eyes darted over to the words on the wall, “You shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free,” (John 8:32). But I didn’t get up. I didn’t feel like my 24-hour bug was worthy. You see, the thing of it was, that I… I… hadn’t really, well, if you want me to be totally transparent and honest about it, the thing is that I hadn’t really had a 24-hour bug… The truth of the matter was that I had wanted a day off from school… to watch TV. I’d only said that I had a 24-hour bug, as an excuse… to get a day off… from school.
So I glued myself to the green cushion that ran the length of my pew and decided that I would get sick soon, really sick, honestly sick, close to dying sick and so that I could have a real Christian Science healing to make up for my pretend 24-hour bug. Then I would rise before the congregation, and give testimony of the divine healing power of Divine Mind.
In the months that followed, my attendance record at school become the worst, I have been told, in the history of Spring Valley Elementary. A meeting was called between my mom, my teacher, Mrs. Schaeffer, and the principal, Mr. Di Cicco, to discuss my horrific attendance and see why I had become so sickly. During this meeting, which I supposedly had a terrible sore throat and stomach ache that had caused me to miss yet another day, I got bored listing to the adults talk and got up out of my chair to run around the room, kicking the kick ball against the wall as hard as I could.
One day, yet a few weeks later, my dad was waterproofing our basement. He had a plastic drum full of chalky white waterproofing powder, which he mixed in batches in a trough, and then broomed against the cinder blocks. I put my face over the drum and a puff of powder flew into my face.
In an instant, I was blind.
I ran upstairs and put my face under the sink, but I couldn’t open my eyes. I tried to hide what had happened, but I was whimpering in fear and my mom found me in the bathroom sobbing. With some more water and toweling, I managed to regain my sight, but my right eye stung like I had poured salt and lemon juice into it.
The next day, Mrs. Schaeffer, stared at me, with my bright pink eye, running nose, and hacking cough. She took me to the nurse, and the two of them discussed the awful looking condition of my face for awhile. Finally they rendered a decision, and in their supreme medical expertise, they decided that maybe I wasn't a faker at all, because clearly I had pink eye. Calls went out to my mom and my dad, neither of whom answered the phone. The nurse went down to the principal’s office and came back with phone numbers for our neighbors. Eventually she managed to get Mrs. Petrusauka, our next-door neighbor on the phone, and explained to her what pink eye was and how she would need to keep me far away from the Petrusauka’s five-year old daughter, Alice. She was also to make absolutely sure that Alice and I did not share a Kleenex.
I tried to process if this was brilliant or inane advice. I had never shared a Kleenex before, but maybe this was common practice among non Christian Scientists. I wasn’t sure. Soon, Mrs. Petrusauka came and drove me to their house, and I sat and watched Sesame Street with Alice. She reminded both of us not to share a Kleenex.
I prayed. I prayed so hard to know the truth, so that the truth would set me free. I prayed to know that I was the perfect image and likeness of God and that I did not have pink eye. I knew that I did not have pink eye.
Actually, that’s completely accurate. I knew that I did not have pink eye.
I knew that I had waterproofing powder in my eye.
But my teacher and the school nurse were under the influence of Mental Malpractice and thus had given me pink eye, conjunctivitis. They had given me a real disease from which I could be healed and give testimony at the First Church of Christ Scientists in Ridgewood, New Jersey.
A few hours later, my mom picked me up and called Mr. Hoffnung. She read to me from the Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures by Mary Baker Eddy and from the Bible. That night, my dad prayed with me. Now, to give both my parents credit, I don’t think they believed I had pink eye…but by the tenets of the church, denial of the existence of a disease is the first step to healing that disease.
My parents didn’t believe I had pink eye, because that’s what they had to believe in order to be good Christian Scientists, not just because they knew I had waterproofing powder in my eye. I prayed all night that, “There is no spot where God is not.” I knew I was the perfect likeness of being of God and that was all that was real about me, not the pink eye.
The next day, I awoke with two white eyes. My coughing was gone. My nose had stopped running. My mom sent me to school, where everyone was astounded to see me in such good shape. Amanda Clemmons studied my eye. It gave me that cold tingling on the back of my neck. The teacher told her to back away so that she didn’t catch my disease. Mrs. Schaeffer was a bitch. I told everyone that I had been healed by Christian Science, which got me beat up at recess.
The next Wednesday service, I went to church with great anticipation. As members of the congregation stood up to give testimony, I felt more and more nervous. At each gap between testimonies, I blanched when Mr. James, the First Reader looked my way with his benign smile. I bunched up the velvet cushion in my fists…and I held myself down to the pew, waiting for the services to end. When they finally did, we all stood up to sing “Onward Christian Soldiers, marching as to war, with the cross of Jesus going on before…” I blasted my voice as loud as I could, giving testimony and thanks to God with the accompaniment of the entire church.
Then I went home and spent the next ten years convinced that I had had a divine healing. If you had met me between 1971 and 1981 and asked me why I believed in Christian Science, I would have told you that I had been healed from pink eye. It’s amazing how much truth we can build upon our own lie.
Mr. Hoffnung and I went on to become very good friends. His office was also in his house, which was surprisingly much nicer than Dr. Pepperman’s house except the black telephones had rotary dials. When I revealed to Mr. Hoffnung that my imaginary friend was the voice in my mind, the voice of God, he said that’s probably right. The voice in my head is God, and then he smiled to reassure me. Mr. Hoffnung was like one of my grandfather’s brothers, nice for no other reason than to be nice. Dr. Pepperman had an underlying purpose to his being nice… he was trying to get me to calm down while he stuck the Bakelite tip of some instrument into my ear or shined some piercing light into my eye. Still, I never once got the cold tingles he always gave me when I saw Mr. Hoffnung. Mr. Hoffnung never once asked me a question about a girl I like. Mr. Hoffnung never once got me to think about Amanda Clemmons…and I liked thinking of Amanda Clemmons.
But here’s the real rub…even though I eventually left the church, when I finally reminded myself of the waterproofing powder, nothing in this story contradicts Christian Science. How’s that possible? What I remembered was that I didn’t really have pink eye, that the pink didn’t exist. Christian Science teaches that we are healed when we realize that we don’t really have a disease, that the disease doesn’t exist. Thus, by my saying that I never had pink eye, I actually prove that I had a Christian Science healing.
Ah forget it…I didn’t have pink eye…that’s the truth, and the truth has set me free.
When Mary Baker Eddy, the discoverer and founder of Christian Science, created the religion in the late 19th Century hospitals were places you went to die. There was no such thing as penicillin. Doctors could only set bones, give you glasses and pull teeth. So Mary told her flock that they may seek medical care for broken bones, eye-glasses and teeth only. She said that for other diseases the cure was to know that they were unreal-- and that as soon as you recognized this fact that they would disappear.
In 1969, when penicillin had been around for 24 years, and doctors could cure a thousand diseases, I made one last visit to mine. Dr. Lionel J. Pepperman was a big, swarthy, gentle pediatrician, whose offices were attached to his house on Farview Avenue. He had medical instruments made out of chrome and Bakelite. I sat on butcher-paper and broke out in goose bumps when Dr. Pepperman asked me if I had a girlfriend. The back of my neck got this fantastic rush of tingles while I thought of all the things I would tell him about Amanda Clemmons, the girl I was in love with, if only I had the nerve to speak. Which, I never did.
Dr. Pepperman had a beige telephone with push button dialing. His fingers smelled like Dial and Kools. And when he gave shots, like for the mumps you could feel the needle go into your arm, but there was no pain.
Still my time with Dr. Pepperman was coming to an end. My mom was a Christian Scientist, named Mary after Mary Baker Eddy herself. My mom a half-Armenian, half-Russian Jew, born in the northeast corner of Tabriz, Iran – the capital of Azeri Persia was in fact named after the WASP discoverer and founder of a marginal Boston-based metaphysical offshoot of Congregationalism. Now I may be going out on a limb here, but I would even hazard a guess that my mom is the only half-Armenian, half-Russian Jew born in an Azeri area of Persia who is named for the blueblood Bostonian founder of a pseudo-ontological Nuevo-Christian denomination… at least the only one in her neighborhood.
About six months after I last saw my pediatrician, I told my mom that I had a 24-hour bug. She asked if I wanted to go to Dr. Pepperman, or did I want her to call Mr. Hoffnung whom I wouldn't have to see. He would pray for me remotely from his home.
You see, Bud Hoffnung was a Christian Science Practitioner. If Dr. Pepperman was nice, Mr. Hoffnung was someone from fairy tale land. He was Mr. Rogers wrapped in a Burl Ives container, filled with love and smiles. And let me tell you something, whatever I may think of Christian Science today, or what you may think of Christian Science today, Mr. Hoffnung was perhaps one of the nicest, kindest, most genuine human beings you could possibly ever meet in your life.
And, if my mom called Mr. Hoffnung, I didn’t have to go anywhere. I could stay home and watch television while my parents paid him to pray for me. Wonder which one I chose?
So I curled up on the mustard coach in our living room, under my blanket and my bedspread, and I watched Captain Kangaroo, Mr. Roger’s Neighborhood, Courageous Cat and Minute Mouse, Gigantor: The Space Age Robot, Lassie, The Lucy Show, The Adams Family, Bachelor Father, Gilligan’s Island, Felix the Cat, Dodo the Kid from Outer Space, and Lost in Space.
All the while, Mr. Hoffnung prayed for me, utilizing the Divine Healing Power of Christian Science in order to see me as God's Perfect Child. This allowed him to heal me by fighting off the Mental Malpractice that had told me that I was sick. And sure enough, the following morning, twenty-four hours after I came down with a 24-hour bug, I was healed – healed without ever once stepping foot within a doctor's office, healed through the power of Divine Love, healed through the power of Christian Science prayer.
Was this the greatest discovery ever? I could be sick whenever I wanted or needed to be and I never had to be checked on again. All I had to do was say I was sick and bingo… we would call Mr. Hoffnung, he would pray for me, and I could watch TV.
Still, there was a catch, because when you have a Christian Science healing, it was hoped that you might give testimony. Christian Science churches had Wednesday Night services, at which one stands up and tells of their healing. I remember at one of the Wednesday Night testimonials one elderly lady saying that she had had something in her eye and at that moment when the pain was the most excruciating; that Divine Mind put a commercial on her television that told her to pull her upper eyelid over her lower eyelid to get rid of the object. She tried this and the item came out, proving God's love.
Between testimonies, the First Reader gazed out at the congregation with a beautiful smile. The First Reader was an elected member of the congregation who led all church services. In Christian Science our preachers were the Bible and The Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures by Mary Baker Eddy. Thus, we only needed a fellow member of the church, a reader to read these to the congregation.
I sat in the pews knowing I should rise and tell my story of being healed from a 24-hour bug in 24-hours. Mr. James, the First Reader cast his smile over to me. It was dark outside and I could feel the cold that had soaked into the windows. My eyes darted over to the words on the wall, “You shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free,” (John 8:32). But I didn’t get up. I didn’t feel like my 24-hour bug was worthy. You see, the thing of it was, that I… I… hadn’t really, well, if you want me to be totally transparent and honest about it, the thing is that I hadn’t really had a 24-hour bug… The truth of the matter was that I had wanted a day off from school… to watch TV. I’d only said that I had a 24-hour bug, as an excuse… to get a day off… from school.
So I glued myself to the green cushion that ran the length of my pew and decided that I would get sick soon, really sick, honestly sick, close to dying sick and so that I could have a real Christian Science healing to make up for my pretend 24-hour bug. Then I would rise before the congregation, and give testimony of the divine healing power of Divine Mind.
In the months that followed, my attendance record at school become the worst, I have been told, in the history of Spring Valley Elementary. A meeting was called between my mom, my teacher, Mrs. Schaeffer, and the principal, Mr. Di Cicco, to discuss my horrific attendance and see why I had become so sickly. During this meeting, which I supposedly had a terrible sore throat and stomach ache that had caused me to miss yet another day, I got bored listing to the adults talk and got up out of my chair to run around the room, kicking the kick ball against the wall as hard as I could.
One day, yet a few weeks later, my dad was waterproofing our basement. He had a plastic drum full of chalky white waterproofing powder, which he mixed in batches in a trough, and then broomed against the cinder blocks. I put my face over the drum and a puff of powder flew into my face.
In an instant, I was blind.
I ran upstairs and put my face under the sink, but I couldn’t open my eyes. I tried to hide what had happened, but I was whimpering in fear and my mom found me in the bathroom sobbing. With some more water and toweling, I managed to regain my sight, but my right eye stung like I had poured salt and lemon juice into it.
The next day, Mrs. Schaeffer, stared at me, with my bright pink eye, running nose, and hacking cough. She took me to the nurse, and the two of them discussed the awful looking condition of my face for awhile. Finally they rendered a decision, and in their supreme medical expertise, they decided that maybe I wasn't a faker at all, because clearly I had pink eye. Calls went out to my mom and my dad, neither of whom answered the phone. The nurse went down to the principal’s office and came back with phone numbers for our neighbors. Eventually she managed to get Mrs. Petrusauka, our next-door neighbor on the phone, and explained to her what pink eye was and how she would need to keep me far away from the Petrusauka’s five-year old daughter, Alice. She was also to make absolutely sure that Alice and I did not share a Kleenex.
I tried to process if this was brilliant or inane advice. I had never shared a Kleenex before, but maybe this was common practice among non Christian Scientists. I wasn’t sure. Soon, Mrs. Petrusauka came and drove me to their house, and I sat and watched Sesame Street with Alice. She reminded both of us not to share a Kleenex.
I prayed. I prayed so hard to know the truth, so that the truth would set me free. I prayed to know that I was the perfect image and likeness of God and that I did not have pink eye. I knew that I did not have pink eye.
Actually, that’s completely accurate. I knew that I did not have pink eye.
I knew that I had waterproofing powder in my eye.
But my teacher and the school nurse were under the influence of Mental Malpractice and thus had given me pink eye, conjunctivitis. They had given me a real disease from which I could be healed and give testimony at the First Church of Christ Scientists in Ridgewood, New Jersey.
A few hours later, my mom picked me up and called Mr. Hoffnung. She read to me from the Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures by Mary Baker Eddy and from the Bible. That night, my dad prayed with me. Now, to give both my parents credit, I don’t think they believed I had pink eye…but by the tenets of the church, denial of the existence of a disease is the first step to healing that disease.
My parents didn’t believe I had pink eye, because that’s what they had to believe in order to be good Christian Scientists, not just because they knew I had waterproofing powder in my eye. I prayed all night that, “There is no spot where God is not.” I knew I was the perfect likeness of being of God and that was all that was real about me, not the pink eye.
The next day, I awoke with two white eyes. My coughing was gone. My nose had stopped running. My mom sent me to school, where everyone was astounded to see me in such good shape. Amanda Clemmons studied my eye. It gave me that cold tingling on the back of my neck. The teacher told her to back away so that she didn’t catch my disease. Mrs. Schaeffer was a bitch. I told everyone that I had been healed by Christian Science, which got me beat up at recess.
The next Wednesday service, I went to church with great anticipation. As members of the congregation stood up to give testimony, I felt more and more nervous. At each gap between testimonies, I blanched when Mr. James, the First Reader looked my way with his benign smile. I bunched up the velvet cushion in my fists…and I held myself down to the pew, waiting for the services to end. When they finally did, we all stood up to sing “Onward Christian Soldiers, marching as to war, with the cross of Jesus going on before…” I blasted my voice as loud as I could, giving testimony and thanks to God with the accompaniment of the entire church.
Then I went home and spent the next ten years convinced that I had had a divine healing. If you had met me between 1971 and 1981 and asked me why I believed in Christian Science, I would have told you that I had been healed from pink eye. It’s amazing how much truth we can build upon our own lie.
Mr. Hoffnung and I went on to become very good friends. His office was also in his house, which was surprisingly much nicer than Dr. Pepperman’s house except the black telephones had rotary dials. When I revealed to Mr. Hoffnung that my imaginary friend was the voice in my mind, the voice of God, he said that’s probably right. The voice in my head is God, and then he smiled to reassure me. Mr. Hoffnung was like one of my grandfather’s brothers, nice for no other reason than to be nice. Dr. Pepperman had an underlying purpose to his being nice… he was trying to get me to calm down while he stuck the Bakelite tip of some instrument into my ear or shined some piercing light into my eye. Still, I never once got the cold tingles he always gave me when I saw Mr. Hoffnung. Mr. Hoffnung never once asked me a question about a girl I like. Mr. Hoffnung never once got me to think about Amanda Clemmons…and I liked thinking of Amanda Clemmons.
But here’s the real rub…even though I eventually left the church, when I finally reminded myself of the waterproofing powder, nothing in this story contradicts Christian Science. How’s that possible? What I remembered was that I didn’t really have pink eye, that the pink didn’t exist. Christian Science teaches that we are healed when we realize that we don’t really have a disease, that the disease doesn’t exist. Thus, by my saying that I never had pink eye, I actually prove that I had a Christian Science healing.
Ah forget it…I didn’t have pink eye…that’s the truth, and the truth has set me free.

